The Kiri tree: a possible alternative or a major problem?
The Kiri, or Paulownia Tormentosa as it is scientifically known, is a species of tree native to China which, it is said, helps to combat climate change. What is not mentioned, however, is that when planted in other ecosystems, it becomes an invasive species, meaning that it manages to establish itself and spread in these new environments, causing severe impacts on biodiversity and the depletion of environmental services.
In Argentina, several provinces have already started planting this species, whilst others see it as a great opportunity; however, biologists from CONICET warn of the potential dangers posed by this exotic species, which is highly likely to become invasive, as it has the capacity to displace native species, thereby creating an imbalance in the ecosystem.
It is said that one of the benefits is its high growth rate, as it absorbs large quantities of carbon dioxide over the course of its life, but what is not mentioned is that it releases it rapidly as it decomposes when it dies; therefore, over its life cycle, the release and absorption cancel each other out, meaning that the benefits it provides in tackling the problem of climate change are minimal.

Furthermore, Colombian scientists who sit on the Government’s National Technical Committee on Invasive Introduced or Transplanted Species consider the kiri to be a potential time bomb: it grows at an astonishing rate, produces thousands of seeds that are dispersed by the wind, new trees can grow from its branches, and it regrows easily after a fire.
These advantages, which make it a highly invasive species that thrives in disturbed environments such as grasslands and riverbanks, are precisely what make it a very difficult plant to control.
That is why, two months ago, this Committee – which is responsible for assessing the risks posed by non-native species arriving in the world’s second most biodiverse country – concluded that it is better to prevent their spread than to regret it later.
Furthermore, studies describe the Kiri as a ‘promising’ species for phytoremediation (decontamination) of soil contaminated with heavy metals. However, according to the US Centre for Invasive Species and Ecosystem Health, this tree species poses an ecological threat; it is aggressive and invades natural areas due to its rapid growth and the absence of competitors and natural enemies.
In conclusion, we can say that there are no advanced or reliable studies to show that the potential benefits of this species outweigh or compensate for the known harm caused by exotic species in a new ecosystem.
So, before planting a new species in a particular location, it is important to bear in mind that:
When it comes to environmental issues, decisions cannot be made in isolation; it is necessary to assess the conditions and the potential changes that may be caused to the balance of ecosystems.
A species that is highly resistant to any climatic conditions can, under ideal conditions, become invasive, displacing native species.
Compared to other species, the Kiri has a very low pollen count, so it would not benefit bee conservation, nor would its contribution in this regard be significant.
And bear in mind that a well-established native species can provide countless ecosystem benefits.
SOURCES:
- INTA, Background and Cultivation of the Paulownia ‘KIRI’ Genus in Argentina, Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Fisheries, Office of the President of Argentina. 2019
EDITORIAL TEAM:
Verónica Beatriz Iraola
Member of Agenda Ambiental Mendoza
Bachelor’s degree in Environmental Information – Master’s degree in Environment and Sustainable Development.



Comments